Elliot vs. Craig as downtown Czar

UPDATE: So, word is, the Mayor-elect chose Craig ... and Elliot.

And Travis Sheridan, Elaine Robles-McGraw, Wilma Quan, and Elizbeth Jonasson. The Bee has a breakdown of what role each will play.

Where will this bring put us this time next year? Hopefully not talking about the same crap, but seeing some hard-core progress being made.

Original post: There's been some scuttlebutt over at The Fresno Bee's Opinion blog about who the Mayor-elect will appoint as her "downtown czar."

I didn't know this was an actual position, but I guess it is and apparently, Craig Scharton's name is being thrown around. Rob Defrees says Elliot Balch would be a better choice. For me, Reza Assemi probably knows more about the problems with downtown (from a developers' standpoint) than anyone. Though, I might go with someone like Joe Moore, too.

So, who do you think would make a good downtown czar?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

try re-reading

it's craig sharton
and
travis sheridan

edluv's picture

Czars are Anti-American Democracy

Craig Sheridan, Travis Sheridan
Nepotism is alive in city government.

Do we really want russian emperors with great power giving us despotic rule?

Famous Guest's picture

guess we got both

http://www.fresnobee.com/updates/story/1100098.html

"Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil."
J. Paul Getty

orcaoid's picture

Battle of the Czars

All I know is that Scharton stiffed me on a drink at Battle of the Bartenders. I mean really, you call that a pour?

Famous Guest's picture

I like Joe

Joe the Moore not Joe the Plumber.
I've always been impressed with his thoughful comments on mindhub and elsewhere. He has a much greater command of downtown details than I have for sure. I only know that I want the lights on in those downtown buildings at night because people live there. Architecture really "Lives" when people live in it. Business follows population.

onomuse's picture

I really don't know if a

I really don't know if a downtown czar would be a good thing in this recession. Adding another employee to the already cash strapped budget doesn't make sense. But, you connected people know more than me. It might be a good thing, but please, no looney tunes.

fresnoise's picture

I vote Craig

But how about a panel to deal with downtown issues.
Cafe Corazon and Le Roi's closing were no big loss.
Savannah's sadly was forced out by unscrupulus property managment.

Famous Guest's picture

Scharton in '09

Craig has been a consistent advocate for revitalizing Downtown Fresno one building, one business at a time -- even when flashy "silver bullet" proposals were getting more airtime. He has experience working with the downtowns of other cities, which I think is tremendously valuable for us, and he is just completing his master's in community and economic development. Talk about bringing in best practices.

In addition, don't overlook Craig's other experience with community and business development, where the goal was consistently to support entrepreneurs and residents themselves, i.e., those who have already invested their own resources and energy in our community. This is the kind of grass-roots mindset that Downtown revitalization must have in common with our city's other community and business development efforts.

So Craig has my vote! But whoever it turns out to be, I hope they'll keep this general approach in mind.

Elliott

PS: If it helps, I will be happy to challenge Craig, Reza, or anyone else to a Downtown duel, such as:
a) A roller blade race from the stadium box office to the spiral garage.
b) A race to plant a tree.
c) Accurately dropping local produce from the top of a tall Downtown building.
d) All of the above: The Downtown Triathlon.

Elliott Balch's picture

It's not either or

I think Ashley Swearengin is smart enough to have both these highly qualified individuals on her team. So it's not an either or situation. I think they will all be working together no matter what title they are appointed.

I for one look forward to the substantial improvements in downtown's built environment that we will see over the next 4 years.

I don't think choosing Reza Assemi is a viable or a good option. He is not a viable option because he is a developer and would have too many conflicts of interest to do an effective and fair job.

He's not a good option because being in that position would only slow the momentum that he has built. To take our most active and productive developers and embed him in buracracy is probably the worst thing we could do for downtown. We want Reza and hopefully other developers focused on developing quality projects.

We want the Downtown Czar to be focused on enabling development, holding the bar high, attracting businesses, and bringing the public downtown.

Kiel Famellos-Schmidt
ArcHop Curator

kiel's picture

with...

businesses closing left and right (Cafe Corazon, Le Roi, Falcons, Savannah's, Olive Press) whoever gets it is gonna have their hands full. That's for sure!

I like them both, but Craig seems more qualified.

press2901's picture

I vote for Reza.

I vote for Reza.

bashfulczar's picture

Post new comment

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <b> <em> <i> <strong> <u> <strike> <p> <br> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Youtube and google video links are automatically converted into embedded videos.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This test is used to prevent spam submissions. All letters are lowercase
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.
Advertisement
Famous Contests